Updating...

3,500 lb. vs 5,200 lb. Trailer Axle: Which One Do You Need

The 3,500 lb. and 5,200 lb. axles are the two most common sizes under utility, car hauler and small equipment trailers. They can look alike from a few feet away, and Dexter builds both in the same hub face and spring center widths. Under the paint they are different axles: a different tube, a different spindle, different bearings, a different bolt pattern in most cases, and a bigger brake on the 5,200 lb. axle.

This guide compares the two side by side, shows how to tell which one your trailer needs, and lists the hubs, brakes, springs and wheels that go with each. It draws on Dexter's 2,000 to 8,000 lb. axle catalog, Dexter's service manual for the same axles, two Dexter product bulletins and our Dexter axle listings. Use it as an overview, not a substitute for the instructions supplied with your axle and parts.

Key takeaways

  • Pick by weight, not by looks. A single 3,500 lb. axle carries 3,500 lbs. A tandem pair of 3,500 lb. axles carries 7,000 lbs. A tandem pair of 5,200 lb. axles carries 10,400 lbs. Every wheel, tire, spring and hanger has to be rated for t he same load.
  • The tube and spindle are bigger on a 5,200 lb. axle. Our 3,500 lb. Dexter axles use a 2-3/8 in. round tube and a spindle with 1-3/8 in. and 1-1/16 in. bearing journals. Our 5,200 lb. Dexter axles use a 3 in. round tube and a spindle with 1-3/4 in. and 1-1/4 in. journals.
  • Hubs and bearings do not swap between them. A 3,500 lb. hub will not fit a 5,200 lb. spindle, and the reverse is also true.
  • Brakes change size. A 3,500 lb. axle uses 10 in. x 2-1/4 in. drum brakes. A 5,200 lb. axle uses 12 in. x 2 in. drum brakes.
  • Lug count is a clue, not a rule. Most 3,500 lb. axles have 5 lug hubs and 5,200 lb. axles have 6 on 5-1/2 in. hubs, but Dexter also offers 6 on 5-1/2 in. hubs for 3,500 lb. axles. Go by the axle tag or the spindle and bearings, not the lug count alone.

Terms used in this guide

  • Axle capacity: The most weight one axle is rated to carry, including the wheels, tires and the share of the trailer and cargo on that axle.
  • GAWR (gross axle weight rating): The axle rating the trailer maker puts on the trailer's VIN label. It is set by the lowest rated part of the running gear.
  • Spindle and bearing journals: The spindle is the machined end of the axle that the hub turns on. The inner and outer journals are the two diameters the bearings sit on.
  • Hub face: The distance across the axle from one wheel mounting face to the other.
  • Spring center: The distance between the centers of the two spring seats on the axle tube.
  • Bolt circle (bolt pattern): The number of wheel studs and the diameter of the circle they sit on, such as 5 on 4-1/2 in. or 6 on 5-1/2 in.
  • Brake size: Drum diameter by brake shoe width, such as 10 in. x 2-1/4 in.

3,500 lb. vs 5,200 lb. axle side by side

These are the specs for the Dexter standard spring axles we stock, from Dexter's catalog and service manual and our listings. Dexter calls these models the D35 and the D52; our listings call the spindles the #84 (3,500 lb.) and the #42 (5,200 lb.).

What to compare 3,500 lb. axle 5,200 lb. axle
Axle tube 2-3/8 in. round, 3/16 in. wall (Dexter's catalog also lists a 3 in. tube option for 3,500 lb. axles) 3 in. round, 3/16 in. wall
Spindle bearing journals 1-3/8 in. inner, 1-1/16 in. outer 1-3/4 in. inner, 1-1/4 in. outer
Inner bearing (cone / cup) L68149 / L68111 25580 / 25520
Outer bearing (cone / cup) L44649 / L44610 15123 / 15245 on the heavy duty hub we use; LM67048 / LM67010 on the light duty hub
Bolt circles Dexter lists 5 on 4-1/2, 5 on 4-3/4, 5 on 5, 5 on 5-1/2 and 6 on 5-1/2 in. 6 on 5-1/2 in. (Dexter notes 8 on 6-1/2 in. hubs are also available)
Wheel studs and nuts 1/2 in.-20 studs, 60 degree cone nuts 1/2 in.-20 studs, 60 degree cone nuts
Drum brake size 10 in. x 2-1/4 in. 12 in. x 2 in.
Dexter electric drum brake rating CSA approved at 3,500 lbs. Used on 5,200 to 7,000 lb. axles; CSA approved at 6,000 lbs. (lining upgrade, Dexter Product Bulletin 382)
Dexter hydraulic drum brake 10 in. x 2-1/4 in., 3,500 lbs. 12 in. x 2 in., 5,200 lbs.
Leaf springs (one per side) 1,750 lb. springs 2,600 lb. springs
Each wheel and each tire, at least 1,750 lbs. 2,600 lbs.
Pre-configured hub face / spring center we stock 61/46, 73/58, 85/70, 89/74 and 95/80 in. 73/58, 85/70, 89/74 and 95/80 in.

The bearing numbers line up with the journal sizes. The L68149 cone has a 1.3775 in. bore and the L44649 cone a 1.0625 in. bore, which match the 3,500 lb. spindle. The 25580 cone has a 1.75 in. bore, and both the 15123 and LM67048 cones have a 1.25 in. bore, which match the 5,200 lb. spindle. For more on reading these numbers, see How to Read a Tapered Roller Bearing Number and Match the Cup and Cone on a Trailer Hub.

Which one do you need?

Start with the weight the axles will carry, not the axle you happen to find. Weigh the loaded trailer, or add the trailer's empty weight to the heaviest load you will haul. Take off the share that rides on the hitch, and the rest is what the axles carry. Our guide Choosing Trailer Axle Capacity: Hitch Weight, GAWR, Wheels and Tires walks through that math step by step.

  • Up to 3,500 lbs. on one axle: A single 3,500 lb. axle.
  • Up to 5,200 lbs. on one axle: A single 5,200 lb. axle.
  • Up to 7,000 lbs. on two axles: A tandem pair of 3,500 lb. axles.
  • Up to 10,400 lbs. on two axles: A tandem pair of 5,200 lb. axles.

Leave room for the heaviest load, not the average one. If your loaded weight is close to the top of a size, step up to the next size.

Remember that an axle is only as strong as the weakest part bolted to it. Dexter's catalog gives this example: if a pair of wheels is rated at 1,500 lbs. each and is used with other parts rated at 4,000 lbs. per axle, the axle assembly can only carry 3,000 lbs. Tires work the same way. So a 5,200 lb. axle on 3,500 lb. tires, wheels or springs is still a 3,500 lb. axle.

If you are replacing an axle, read the tag on the old axle first, or measure it. See How to Measure for a Custom Dexter Trailer Axle. A quick check: measure the tube. A 2-3/8 in. tube points to a 3,500 lb. axle, and a 3 in. tube with 6 lug hubs and 12 in. brakes points to a 5,200 lb. axle. Some 3,500 lb. axles are built on a 3 in. tube, so confirm with the tag or the bearing numbers.

Wheels and tires for each size

Every axle has two wheels and two tires, so each wheel and each tire must carry at least half the axle rating: 1,750 lbs. on a 3,500 lb. axle and 2,600 lbs. on a 5,200 lb. axle.

Always confirm the rating on the listing for the exact part number. Both sizes use 1/2 in.-20 studs and 60 degree cone nuts, and Dexter's service manual gives the same torque for 14 in. to 16 in. wheels on either axle: 20-25 ft. lbs., then 50-60 ft. lbs., then 100-120 ft. lbs., in the tightening sequence Dexter shows for 5 and 6 bolt wheels. Re-torque after the first 10, 25 and 50 miles. For how to add up wheel ratings, see Trailer Wheel Load Ratings and Hub Pilot vs Stud Pilot Wheels.

Hubs, bearings and seals

This is where the two axles differ the most. The spindles are different sizes, so the hubs, bearings and seals are not interchangeable. Order hubs by axle capacity and bolt circle.

Part 3,500 lb. axle 5,200 lb. axle
Idler hub with parts TruRyde 5 on 4-1/2 in., 545LB1E, Timken bearings, 545LB1E-TK, pre-greased, PP-RVIK-3PG, Dexter pre-greased, K08-248-1G TruRyde 6 on 5-1/2 in., 13HLB1E, Timken bearings, 13HLB1E-TK, pre-greased, PP-RVIK-8PG
6 on 5-1/2 in. hub TruRyde 6 on 5-1/2 in. for a 3,500 lb. axle, 655LB1E Standard on this axle (see above)
Inner bearing and race L68149 / L68111, Dexter K71-390-00 25580 / 25520, Dexter K71-308-00
Outer bearing and race L44649 / L44610, Dexter K71-306-00 15123 / 15245: TruRyde 15123 bearing and TruRyde 15245 race (heavy duty hub, the one we use) or LM67048 / LM67010, Dexter K71-307-00 (light duty hub)
Grease seal Dexter K71-303-00, 1.72 in. ID Dexter K71-305-00, 2.250 in. ID (2.25 in. seal journal); older axles may have a 2.12 in. journal

One thing to know about the 5,200 lb. axle: two hubs fit the same spindle. The light duty hub uses an LM67048 cone and LM67010 cup outer bearing. The heavy duty hub uses a 15123 cone and 15245 cup outer bearing, and it is the one we use. Dexter Product Bulletin 479 (May 8, 2023) moved Dexter's 5,200 lb. production axles to the heavy duty hub. The spindle, the axle rating and the 6 on 5-1/2 in. bolt pattern are the same, so wheels fit either hub. During service, Dexter says to replace the outer cone or cup with the same type that came out, because they do not interchange between the two hubs. Read the numbers off your old bearings before you order.

See all 3,500 lb. trailer axle hubs with parts and 5,200 lb. trailer axle hubs with parts.

Brakes for each size

Our pre-configured 3,500 lb. and 5,200 lb. Dexter axles both come with brake flanges, so you can add brakes now or later. The brake size has to match the axle:

Each TruRyde electric brake kit above covers one axle: two hub and drums plus a left and a right brake. Dexter's service manual lists the same 3.0 amp draw per magnet for 10 in. x 2-1/4 in. and 12 in. x 2 in. electric brakes, so a tandem trailer draws about 12 amps at full braking with either size, and the same brake controller works with both. For help choosing a kit, see How to Choose a TruRyde Drum Brake Kit: Electric vs Hydraulic, Capacity and Axle Count or How to Choose a DeeMaxx Disc Brake Kit: Slip-Over vs Integral, Capacity and Axle Count. All 5,200 lb. electric kits are in 5,200 lb. trailer axle electric brake kits.

Springs, hangers and U-bolts

The suspension has to match the axle capacity and the tube size:

More options are in Suspension Kits, Springs, Hangers, and U-bolts.

Pre-configured Dexter axles we stock in both sizes

Our pre-configured Dexter standard spring axles are straight, cambered, underslung beams with E-Z Lube spindles, brake flanges and pre-welded spring seats. They are the beam only; hubs, springs, hangers and U-bolts are sold separately. Four of the widths come in both capacities, so the same frame width can take either size:

Hub face Spring center 3,500 lb. axle 5,200 lb. axle
61 in. 46 in. 12460348 Not stocked; see custom built
73 in. 58 in. 12404166 12460384
85 in. 70 in. 12427928 12412211
89 in. 74 in. 12460373 12460390
95 in. 80 in. 12431370 12460393

Browse 3,500 lb. straight Dexter trailer axles and 5,200 lb. straight Dexter trailer axles. Need a width or option that is not listed? Order one in Custom Built Dexter Trailer Axles, and see Custom Built vs Pre-Configured Dexter Axles: Which to Order.

Going from a 3,500 lb. to a 5,200 lb. axle

Swapping a 3,500 lb. axle for a 5,200 lb. axle is more than a beam change. Plan on replacing:

  • The axle beam (3 in. tube in place of 2-3/8 in.).
  • The hubs or hub and drums, bearings and seals (new spindle size).
  • The brakes, if the trailer has them (12 in. x 2 in. in place of 10 in. x 2-1/4 in.).
  • The wheels, if the old hubs were 5 lug (new 6 on 5-1/2 in. bolt circle), and any wheel or tire rated under 2,600 lbs.
  • The springs (2,600 lb.), the U-bolts and tie plates (3 in. tube), and any hanger, shackle or equalizer parts not rated for 5,200 lbs.

A bigger axle also does not raise the trailer's rating by itself. Dexter's catalog puts the job of evaluating, specifying and certifying the trailer and running gear combination on the trailer maker, and the frame, coupler and every other part were picked for the original rating. If you need more capacity than the trailer was built for, check with the trailer maker first.

Checklist before you order

  1. Weigh the loaded trailer or add up its empty weight plus the heaviest load.
  2. Pick the capacity and the number of axles from that weight, with room to spare.
  3. Read the old axle tag, or measure hub face, spring center and tube diameter.
  4. Note the bolt circle and read the numbers off the old bearings and seal.
  5. Decide on brakes: none, electric, hydraulic or disc, in the size for that axle.
  6. Match springs, U-bolts, hangers, wheels and tires to the same capacity.
  7. Call us if any measurement or number does not line up.

Safety note

Never load an axle past its rating or the rating of its weakest part. Use only parts made for the axle's capacity and spindle, torque wheel nuts in stages to the listed values, and follow the brake and bearing instructions supplied with your parts. If you are not sure, have a qualified trailer shop do the work.

FAQ

What is the difference between a 3,500 lb. and a 5,200 lb. trailer axle?

The 5,200 lb. axle has a 3 in. tube in place of a 2-3/8 in. tube, a larger spindle with different bearings, 6 on 5-1/2 in. hubs, 12 in. x 2 in. brakes in place of 10 in. x 2-1/4 in., and it needs 2,600 lb. springs, wheels and tires in place of 1,750 lb.

Do 3,500 lb. and 5,200 lb. axles use the same hubs?

No. The spindles and bearings are different sizes, so the hubs do not swap. Even a 6 on 5-1/2 in. hub made for a 3,500 lb. axle will not fit a 5,200 lb. spindle.

Is every 6 lug trailer axle a 5,200 lb. axle?

No. Dexter offers 6 on 5-1/2 in. hubs for 3,500 lb. axles too. Check the axle tag, the tube diameter or the bearing numbers.

How much can a tandem 3,500 lb. or 5,200 lb. axle trailer carry?

Two 3,500 lb. axles carry up to 7,000 lbs., and two 5,200 lb. axles carry up to 10,400 lbs., as long as the wheels, tires, springs and hangers are rated for it. The trailer's own rating on its VIN label still sets the limit.

What size brakes go on a 5,200 lb. axle?

12 in. x 2 in. drum brakes. We use the 12 in. x 2 in. electric brake on 5,200 to 7,000 lb. axles, and Dexter's upgraded lining is rated at 6,000 lbs. A 3,500 lb. axle uses 10 in. x 2-1/4 in. brakes.

Why does my Dexter 5,200 lb. axle have a 15123 outer bearing?

It has the heavy duty hub, which uses a 15123 cone and 15245 cup outer bearing. The light duty hub uses an LM67048 cone and LM67010 cup. Dexter has built its 5,200 lb. axles with the heavy duty hub since 2023, and it is the hub we use. Replace the bearing with the same type that came out.

Can I use the same wheels on a 3,500 lb. and a 5,200 lb. axle?

Only if the bolt circle matches and each wheel is rated for at least 2,600 lbs. A 6 on 5-1/2 in. wheel rated 2,850 lbs. works on either axle with 6 on 5-1/2 in. hubs. A 5 lug wheel rated 1,870 lbs. is fine for a 3,500 lb. axle but will not fit or carry a 5,200 lb. axle.

References

  • Dexter Axle. Light Duty Catalog, 600 to 8,000 lbs. axle capacity (LIT-122-00, 2020.05): Important Information; 2,300 to 4,000 lbs. and 4,100 to 6,000 lbs. application information; 545 and other hub group for D35; 655 hub group for D52/D60; 10 in. x 2-1/4 in. and 12 in. x 2 in. brake pages; leaf spring and U-bolt and tie plate tables.
  • Dexter Axle. 2,000 to 8,000 lbs. Axle Operation Maintenance Service Manual: wheel torque requirements, magnet amperes chart, seal replacement reference, bearing replacement chart.
  • Dexter Axle. Product Bulletin #479, 5,200 lbs. Hub and Hub-Drum Obsolescence - Axle Production (May 8, 2023).
  • Dexter Axle. Product Bulletin #382, 12 in. x 2 in. 6,000 lb. Brake Lining Change (November 16, 2015).
  • TrailStar. Trailer tire and wheel catalog (2020), trailer wheels.

Related guides

Find the right Dexter axle

Have your loaded trailer weight, number of axles, hub face, spring center, bolt circle and brake needs ready when you shop or call. Southwest Wheel has supplied trailer parts for 107 years, and we can help you match a 3,500 lb. or 5,200 lb. axle with the hubs, brakes, springs and wheels that go with it.

Shop Pre-Configured Dexter Trailer Axles

Need a different size? See custom built Dexter trailer axles or trailer hubs with parts.

Call Southwest Wheel at 1-800-866-3336.

Southwest Wheel - Your Trailers Best Friend Since 1919.

 
Sign Up For Special Offers and News!

Get 5% off your first purchase , information on newest offers, and useful tips on how to get the most out of our services.

Valid once per customer on first purchase only. Not combinable with other offers or past orders.
 
Loading...